They got the wrong party and roughly treated the arrested man. The current holder of that IP address instead of They contacted the ISP and they fingered a wrong party. Looks like, Google provided the IP address of someone who posted derogatory images of Shivaji to the Indian authorities. But remember Google was (presumably) obeying a court order. On top of this, the president wants to grant these telecoms retroactive immunity from prosecution, since he asked them to do it.Īnd on top of all this, Americans have the nerve to get their knickers in a twist when another American company Obeys the laws of a country in which they do business?īy all means campaign to change the attitudes of those in power in repressive countries. On top of this, nearly all US phone companies are implicated in spying on US citizens illegally, allowing the FBI/CIA etc who-knows-what access to every phone call handled. On top of this, the PATRIOT act (which has everything to do with undermining the constitution and nothing to do with true patriotism) now makes it possible to send US citizens to Gitmo. ![]() None have yet received any form of trial, with some having been held for 6 years. There is very good evidence to say that many, if not most, held there are entirely innocent. Of all the British citizens sent to Guatanamo Bay, those sent back to Britain to handle have been released with no charges. Yes, as time goes on, I think they are slipping and getting shady, but a large group of people in the company sincerely care about this aspect of the Google culture. ![]() This way they could follow the laws of the local country, help those people get better information for a large percentage of searches and they would still be able to access the uncensored version of like they had been able to all along. They weren't just ignoring the evil of censorship, they eventually came to the decision that the Chinese users would still be able to access to get their uncensored results if they were searching sensitive topics, but if they were just doing mundane searches having a locally served and maintained google.cn would provide those users with a better experience and better search. Censoring results for Google China was a HUGE debate within the company and they sincerely cared about the issue. The problem is that there is a big grey area and they acknowledge that in their debates. The people in the company really do care about the idea of doing good and avoiding evil. Arguments and debates break out amongst engineers about certain features of software or actions of the company. How is that "trumpeting it loudly".? I worked at Google for several years. Google, as best as I can tell, has it on two of their pages. I don't exactly see Google trumpeting the damn thing. If refusing to give the IP address would've gotten them banned from providing service, then turning over the IP address may in fact have been the lesser of two evils. That is, this is probably not a case of there being a clear evil choice (turn over the IP address) and a not-evil choice (don't turn over the IP address). Google and Yahoo may be trying to walk a fine line between offering the citizens of those countries access to information, while simultaneously trying to avoid getting banned. ![]() Do you wait until a rogue country changes its political ideals to sufficiently match yours before you conduct business with them? Or do you partially compromise your ideals and conduct business with them in the hopes that it will accelerate those changes? ![]() This is pretty much the same issue that's been debated ever since Nixon normalized relations with China. Do you believe civil rights and freedom would be promoted in India and China if Google and Yahoo were banned there? Need I point out that the government of China is working on a (government-controlled) search engine like Google and would like nothing more than for Google (and Yahoo and Wikipedia) to disappear from their neck of the Internet. Google and Yahoo don't want to take a chance of being banned in a country of that size, so they do whatever the governments of these countries want. And the problem is that India and China are huge countries.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |